Rule of 40 for a Trades Business: Judging HVAC Like a Software Company
The Rule of 40 is a software screening heuristic. How I use growth plus profit margin as a planning discipline, my 20% tripwire, and why free cash flow and returns on capital decide.
Correction note. Updated November 15, 2026: We revised this article after an internal editorial review and an independent review. The original version said the Rule of 40 "applies to home services" and that a score of 40 means a business is healthy. That went further than the evidence: the Rule of 40 is a screening heuristic from software investing, and we found no published study testing it on trades businesses. This version adds sources for the rule's origin and its critics. It separates my own 20% EBITDA tripwire from the Rule of 40 target and labels my score bands as my own judgment thresholds, not validated cutoffs. It reframes the 25-to-40 band as "explain the gap" rather than a verdict, and adds a section on free cash flow and returns on capital. It also adds the strongest argument against using the rule in our industry, plus the limits of the score. We also removed descriptions of personal experiences that we could not document: an anecdote about owners' reactions when I mention the rule, a claim about how often I bring it up, a claim that most people in the trades have never heard of it, and a line saying our plans "got more honest". The original illustrative example ($5.0M revenue, 19% growth, 12% margin, score 31) is unchanged.
Short answer: The Rule of 40 is a quick screen from software investing: revenue growth rate plus profit margin should reach about 40%. The profit measure varies. Most people use EBITDA margin, and some use free cash flow margin, and the choice can change the answer. We found no published evidence validating it for trades businesses. The published work we reviewed concerns software companies. I still use it as a planning discipline, because it puts growth and profit on the same scale. Separately, I have my own minimum: if there is no 20% profit at the bottom, the top line has to grow by more than 20%. That is my management philosophy, not an industry requirement. Treat the score as a question to answer, not a verdict. Then check two things the score leaves out: does growth turn into cash, and does it earn more than the capital it uses?

The thesis, in my words and in plain terms
This is how I put it in a planning meeting in November 2026: "The Rule of 40 has to work. … That is 10% EBITDA and 30% growth, or 20% growth and 20% EBITDA. … That's considered normal for a healthy business. … If there's no 20% profit at the bottom, then the top line has to grow by more than 20%." (Translated from Russian. The ellipses mark where separate remarks from the same discussion are joined.)
Those are my words, and they describe my standard. "Healthy" is the word I used in that meeting. The evidence we reviewed supports something narrower: 40 is a useful target, not proof that a business is healthy.
The claim underneath my words is simpler and, I think, defensible. A trades business should judge growth and profit together, because either one can look good while the other quietly gets worse. The specific number, 40, is borrowed from software. Using it for an HVAC or plumbing company is an experiment, not an established standard.
Why it matters
A revenue target is easy to write. "Grow 20% next year" sounds good in a meeting. But if that 20% comes with the same thin margin, or with a margin that shrinks because the growth was bought with discounts, ad spend or acquisitions, the business may be bigger without being better. A margin target can fail the other way, by cutting the investments next year's revenue depends on. Putting both numbers on one scale makes the trade-off visible before the plan is locked.
Where the rule comes from: the evidence
Origin. In a February 3, 2015 post, venture investor Brad Feld wrote that a late-stage investor had described "the 40% rule for a healthy software company." Feld framed it for SaaS companies "at scale – assume at least $50 million in revenue." He noted that "Profit is harder to define," and said he preferred EBITDA as the baseline, back-tested against other measures. (Feld Thoughts, 2015)
How it spread. Bain & Company's 2018 brief says venture capitalists began popularizing the rule in 2015 as a health check for SaaS companies. Bain notes that analysts differ on the profit measure: "most use EBITDA, but some have proposed free cash flow, EBIT or net income." Of 86 companies Bain studied from 2013 to 2017, 25% beat the rule for three or more years, and 16% beat it in all five. (Bain, 2018)
A different profit measure. McKinsey's 2021 article defines the rule using free cash flow margin. Across more than 200 software companies from 2011 to 2021, companies exceeded it only 16% of the time. Investors rewarded companies at or above 40 with higher enterprise-value-to-revenue multiples. (McKinsey, 2021)
No single right mix. A 2024 McKinsey analysis argues that the value-maximizing balance of growth and margin differs by company. It depends on cost of capital, growth efficiency and growth headroom. (McKinsey, 2024)
Even software moves the bar. In April 2026, Bain wrote that "investing to keep up with new competitors may force SaaS companies to accept the Rule of 30 for a while." It pointed to rising AI costs and to reinvestment to compete with AI-native rivals. (Bain, 2026)
Physical businesses, from one of the investors who popularized it. In June 2026, Feld asked whether the rule works for hardware companies. His answer was yes, "but you have to read the curve, not the snapshot." He also wrote: "A hardware company doing everything right can fail the Rule of 40 for years." He notes that Bessemer's "Rule of X" weights growth more heavily than profit, and says "the moment you start weighting the inputs, you're admitting the flat number was never the whole story." (Feld Thoughts, June 15, 2026)
What this supports: the Rule of 40 is a widely used software heuristic. In the software samples studied, scoring at or above it has been associated with higher valuations. People use different profit definitions, and the rule is hard to sustain. Even its best-known advocate reads it as a trend, not a single-period verdict, for capital-heavy companies.
What it doesn't establish: that 40 is the right bar for a trades company, or that a high score causes higher value. The findings are correlations from software samples. We found practitioner commentary suggesting the rule can apply beyond software (for example, Chenmark, 2017), but no published study testing it on trades businesses. Until such work turns up, it's a borrowed lens.
Two different tests: my tripwire and the Rule of 40 target
My 20% rule and the Rule of 40 are related, but they are not the same test.
My tripwire (my minimum, my philosophy): if EBITDA margin is below 20%, revenue growth has to be above 20%. It's a minimum I set for my own plans. It stops a plan from accepting a thin margin without a growth story to pay for it.
The Rule of 40 target (borrowed from software): growth plus margin should be at least 40.
They agree at exactly 20 and 20. Below a 20% margin, they diverge. Take a hypothetical plan with a 12% margin:
The tripwire asks for growth above 20%.
The 40 target asks for growth of at least 28% (40 − 12).
A plan with 24% growth clears my tripwire but scores 36 against the target.
Above a 20% margin, the tripwire stops applying, but the target still does. At a hypothetical 25% margin, the target asks for 15% growth.
Why the tripwire can't work alone. Taken by itself, the tripwire would pass a hypothetical plan with a 2% margin and 21% growth, a score of 23. It would fail a plan with a 19% margin and 20% growth, a score of 39. The plan that passes scores 16 points lower than the plan that fails. That is the case for keeping the 40 target alongside the tripwire.
Here's how I use the two together. The tripwire is my first check. It's quick and binary, and it tells me whether a thin-margin plan has a growth case at all. Then I compare the plan against 40. A plan that clears the tripwire but falls short of 40 isn't rejected automatically. It has to explain the gap. Then I check cash and returns.
How to calculate it, and what to disclose
Growth. Compare trailing twelve months of revenue with the twelve months before. Split it into organic and acquired growth. Estimate roughly how much came from price and how much from volume, because in an inflationary year much of the "growth" can be price.
Profit. State which measure you use. If you use EBITDA margin, use a market salary for the owner and list one-time costs separately. Recurring "one-time" costs don't belong in that list.
Add them. That's the score: a starting point for questions.
Illustrative example: these are made-up numbers for a hypothetical company, not Home Alliance figures and not an industry benchmark.
Revenue, last twelve months: $5.0M
Revenue, the twelve months before: $4.2M
EBITDA, last twelve months, after a market salary for the owner: $600K
Growth: ($5.0M − $4.2M) ÷ $4.2M ≈ 19%. EBITDA margin: $600K ÷ $5.0M = 12%. Score: 19 + 12 = 31.
Margin is under 20% and growth is just under 20%, so this plan fails my tripwire, and it's 9 points short of the 40 target. That doesn't tell you whether the business is good. It tells you where to look.

How I read the score: my judgment thresholds, not validated cutoffs
The bands below are my judgment thresholds. They have not been validated as cutoffs. I use them to decide what to check next, not as a verdict.
Around 40 or above: The plan meets the target. That is not proof of health. A company can score 40 on EBITDA and still burn cash, carry too much debt or depend on one customer. Check those before drawing conclusions.
About 25 to 40: The plan is below the target, but that alone isn't a verdict. The gap can sit on growth, on margin or on both; a hypothetical 15% margin with 15% growth is short on neither side in particular. The plan has to explain the gap. Either it shows which lever closes the gap and by when, or it shows why a sub-40 mix is right for this business right now. One hypothetical example is a steady, cash-generating company earning a 20% margin on 10% growth.
Below about 25: Look harder before adding complexity. The low score might come from deliberate investment, a mild weather year, aggressive add-backs or weak pricing and productivity. For a buyer or investor, a company below 25 can still be an attractive opportunity. That depends on the price, the turnaround potential, the capital needed and the expected return.
EBITDA is not cash: free cash flow and returns on capital
This is where the Rule of 40 is weakest for a trades business, and where most of the real judgment sits.
EBITDA leaves out capital spending. In our industry, growth runs on trucks, tools, equipment, inventory and sometimes a new location. It also ties up working capital: receivables from commercial customers, customer financing, parts on the shelf. McKinsey's version of the rule uses free cash flow instead, defined as cash flow from operations minus capital expenditures.
Two distinctions matter:
Maintenance capex vs growth capex. Replacing a worn-out truck keeps current revenue running. That's a cost of standing still, and EBITDA ignores it. Adding trucks for new technicians is an investment in growth, and it should be judged by what it returns.
Growth that earns more than its capital costs vs growth that doesn't. The test is incremental return on invested capital: the extra after-tax operating profit from growth, divided by the extra capital the growth needed. If that return is below your cost of capital, the growth makes the company bigger and less valuable at the same time.
Illustrative example: made-up numbers continuing the same hypothetical company. The 25% tax rate and 12% cost of capital are assumptions for the arithmetic, not benchmarks. A real company's cost of capital moves with interest rates and with how risky lenders and owners judge the business.
Assume EBITDA the year before was $460K, so growth added $140K of EBITDA ($600K − $460K) on $0.8M of new revenue. Now compare two ways the same company could have produced exactly the same growth and the same EBITDA-based score of 31.
Path A: capital-light growth | Path B: capital-heavy growth | |
|---|---|---|
EBITDA | $600K | $600K |
Maintenance capex | $100K | $100K |
Growth capex | $150K (two trucks) | $1,000K (new location and fleet) |
Increase in working capital | $100K | $200K |
Cash flow before interest and tax (EBITDA − capex − increase in working capital) | $250K (5% of revenue) | −$700K (−14% of revenue) |
Extra capital invested for growth | $250K | $1,200K |
Extra depreciation (Path A: $150K over 5 years; Path B: $1,000K over 10 years) | $30K | $100K |
Extra operating profit ($140K − depreciation) | $110K | $40K |
After 25% tax | $82.5K | $30K |
Incremental return on invested capital, first year | 33% ($82.5K ÷ $250K) | 2.5% ($30K ÷ $1,200K) |
Versus an assumed 12% cost of capital | Above | Below |
McKinsey's free cash flow is measured after interest and tax. The cash-flow row above is before both, so read it as a pre-tax, unlevered stand-in. On McKinsey's definition, both figures would be lower.
The EBITDA-based score is identical, and the economics are opposite. On a cash-flow version of the rule, closer to McKinsey's, they aren't even close. Using the table's cash flow as the margin, Path A scores about 24 (19 + 5) and Path B about 5 (19 − 14). Path A turns growth into cash and earns well above its cost of capital. Path B grows just as fast, burns $700K of cash in the year and earns far less than the capital costs. A 10-year life is generous for trucks, and a shorter one would make Path B look worse, not better.
There's one fair caveat. The return above is measured on the first year. A new location may need two or three years to reach full productivity, so a one-year snapshot can understate Path B. Judge it again on the run-rate year. That's Feld's point about hardware: read the curve, not the snapshot. The honest version of that argument is an explicit ramp plan with a date by which the return has to clear the cost of capital, not a hope.
The strongest counterargument
The best case against using the rule in our industry goes like this, and I take it seriously.
The Rule of 40 grew up in software. SaaS companies have long benefited from low marginal costs (Bain, 2026). Their growth spending runs mostly through the income statement, and much of their revenue is recurring. A trades company differs on each point: growth needs trucks, people and working capital; a good share of revenue is not contracted; and weather drives demand. Adding one point of growth to one point of margin assumes the two are worth the same. Even in software, alternatives such as Bessemer's Rule of X weight them differently (as Feld describes it, 2026). In a capital- and labor-heavy business, they often aren't worth the same. Here is a hypothetical comparison. A company growing 3% at a 20% margin, with low debt and strong cash conversion, scores 23. It may still be a better business than one growing 30% at a 10% EBITDA margin that needs a truck, a hire and a financing line for every new dollar of revenue.
What this tells me: the score is weakest exactly where trades companies differ most from software, which is capital, cash and labor. So the score opens the conversation, and free cash flow and incremental returns finish it.
Boundary conditions: when the score misleads
Acquired growth. A hypothetical score of 45 built on an acquisition and a shrinking core is a warning sign. Always show organic and acquired growth separately.
Price versus volume. Growth that comes mostly from price increases can flatter the score while the business serves fewer customers.
Quality of EBITDA. If the margin only reaches 20% after a long list of add-backs, expect a buyer to discount it, and discount it yourself.
Debt and liquidity. Two companies with the same score can carry very different risk if one financed its growth with debt it has to refinance in a bad year.
Seasonality and weather. Trailing twelve months helps but doesn't remove weather. A twelve-month window can still be one unusually hot year. Look at two or three years when you can.
Labor. In a trades company, revenue growth usually needs more technicians. The Bureau of Labor Statistics projects employment of HVAC mechanics and installers to grow 11% from 2025 to 2035, "much faster than the average for all occupations." It also projects about 40,600 openings a year, on average, many of them to replace workers who leave the occupation (BLS). Those figures show sustained hiring demand, not a shortage in any one market. A high growth number needs a hiring and training plan behind it.
Customer concentration. Growth tied to one large commercial account, one builder or one referral partner can disappear in a quarter.
Strategic implications
For operators: Use the tripwire and the target to force a choice. Will next year be mainly a growth plan or a margin plan, and which three levers will get you there? On the growth side: close rates in the home, maintenance agreements, new services for existing customers, and new territories once the core is solid. On the margin side: pricing that reflects the real cost of a truck, a technician and a warranty; fewer callbacks; technician productivity; overhead that grows slower than revenue; and marketing tied to results. Then put each growth lever through the capital test above.
Incentives follow the same logic. My principle is that a bonus is paid when a plan is hit and the money is actually earned, and that you don't pay twice for the same hours: if one person covers two roles at the same time, those are still the same hours. If the business is judged on growth plus profit, rewards should follow growth plus profit, not effort alone.
For buyers and investors: The score is a fast first filter, nothing more. The valuation link in the research was measured in software companies. It says nothing about what a trades business is worth, and borrowing a software metric doesn't earn a software multiple.
For anyone running several units: Calculate the score, free cash flow and incremental return for each unit, not just the total. One strong unit can hide several weak ones.
Practical application: a 30-day trial
Week 1: Pull trailing twelve months of revenue and the twelve months before, EBITDA with a market owner salary and every add-back, operating cash flow, and capex split into maintenance and growth. Pull two or three years if you have them.
Week 2: Calculate the score. Split growth into organic and acquired, and roughly into price and volume. Check the tripwire.
Week 3: For each growth lever, estimate the extra capital it needs and the extra profit it should earn. Drop or redesign levers that can't plausibly beat your cost of capital.
Week 4: Put the score, free cash flow and incremental return on one page. Review it quarterly on a trailing twelve-month basis.

Frequently asked questions
What is the Rule of 40?
It's a heuristic from software investing: revenue growth rate plus profit margin should be at least 40%. Brad Feld described it in 2015. Bain and McKinsey have studied it in software companies using EBITDA or free cash flow.
Does the Rule of 40 apply to HVAC and home services?
We found no published evidence validating it for trades businesses; the research we reviewed concerns software companies. It can still be a useful planning discipline if you disclose your profit measure, separate organic from acquired growth, look at more than one year, and check free cash flow and returns on capital alongside it.
What is a good EBITDA margin for a home services company?
I won't give you a benchmark I can't source. My own minimum is the tripwire: below 20% EBITDA, growth has to be above 20%. That's a management choice, not an industry norm.
Conclusion: what's supported, what isn't, what to test
Supported: The Rule of 40 is a widely used software heuristic with a documented origin around 2015. In software samples, meeting it has been associated with higher valuations. Few software companies sustain it.
My philosophy: Judge growth and profit on one scale. Hold to a 20% tripwire: no 20% profit at the bottom, then more than 20% growth at the top.
Not established: That 40, or my 25 and 40 bands, are the right cutoffs for a trades company, or that a high score means value is being created in a capital- and labor-heavy business.
What I'd test next: Across several years of trades-company data, does a combined growth-plus-margin score tell you anything about cash generation or value that free cash flow and incremental returns on capital don't? Until then, the rule is how I start the conversation, and cash and returns are how I finish it.